GST Simplified: Key Advantages and Disadvantages You Need to Know

What Is GST?

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a revolutionary tax reform that represents a single, unified indirect tax system in India. It encompasses various central and state taxes into one tax regime, levied on the manufacture, sale, and consumption of goods and services throughout the country. GST is a destination-based, multi-stage tax, applied at every point of sale, where the final consumer bears the tax. It is charged on the value added at each stage of the supply chain, allowing for the seamless flow of input tax credit, thereby reducing the overall cost of goods and services and eliminating the cascading effect of taxes.

GST is categorized into four types based on the nature of the transaction: Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST), State Goods and Services Tax (SGST), Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST), and Union Territory Goods and Services Tax (UTGST). CGST and SGST/UTGST are levied on intra-state transactions, shared between the central and state governments, while IGST is charged on inter-state transactions and imports, accruing to the central government but shared with the destination state.

Why Was GST Introduced in India?

GST was introduced in India to address and rectify a fragmented and complex indirect tax structure that was full of inefficiencies and the cascading effect of taxes. Prior to GST, the Indian tax system consisted of various taxes levied by the central and state governments, including but not limited to Value Added Tax (VAT), Service Tax, Excise Duty, and Central Sales Tax (CST). This system not only made tax compliance cumbersome for businesses but also led to the double taxation of goods and services, inflating costs for consumers and creating barriers to a unified national market.

The primary objectives behind the introduction of GST were:

1. To Eliminate the Cascading Effect of Taxes: GST was designed to remove the tax-on-tax effect, ensuring that taxes paid on inputs could be availed as credit, thereby reducing the final cost to the consumer.
2. To Simplify the Tax Structure: By consolidating multiple indirect taxes into a single tax, GST simplified the tax regime, making it easier for businesses to comply and for the government to administer.
3. To Enhance Compliance and Broaden the Tax Base: A simpler tax system, coupled with technology-driven compliance mechanisms under GST, aimed to improve tax compliance rates and broaden the tax base.
4. To Boost the Economy and Promote Growth: By reducing the cost of goods and services, GST aimed to stimulate consumer demand, promote economic growth, and enhance the competitiveness of Indian goods and services in the global market.
5. To Create a Unified National Market: GST sought to break down fiscal barriers between states, facilitating the free flow of goods and services across the country, thereby creating a single, unified national market.

The introduction of GST on July 1, 2017, marked a significant milestone in India's economic history, representing the culmination of years of effort towards tax reform aimed at fostering a more transparent, efficient, and growth-oriented tax environment.

Must reads

RCM Invoice Format Under GST

• 6 Nov 24
• 10 mins

What Causes the Mismatch Between GSTR 2A and 3B in Tax Returns?

• 22 Aug 24
• 15 mins

Types of Tax Levied as GST

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) framework in India has significantly transformed the landscape of indirect taxation, streamlining tax burdens and simplifying compliance for business owners. This unified tax system, aimed at reducing the cascading effect of taxes on goods and services, encompasses four primary types of taxes. Each of these taxes plays a crucial role in the filing of GST returns, GST registration, and adherence to the Composition Scheme. Here's an overview of each tax type within the GST regime:

Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST)

CGST is a core component of India's GST system, representing the central element of indirect taxation on intra-state transactions. Business owners are required to pay CGST on all transactions occurring within a single state, alongside SGST or UTGST. This necessitates accurate GST registration and diligent filing of GST returns to ensure compliance. The revenue collected under CGST contributes to the central government's finances, streamlining the tax structure and reducing tax burdens.

State Goods and Services Tax (SGST)

SGST stands as the state counterpart to CGST, levied on intra-state supplies of goods and services. It mandates business owners to manage their tax liabilities efficiently, incorporating SGST charges in their tax returns. The introduction of SGST has unified various state-level taxes under the GST umbrella, simplifying the indirect taxation system and easing the tax burdens on consumers and businesses alike. The revenue from SGST directly benefits the state governments, supporting local infrastructure and services.

Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST)

IGST is designed to address the complexities of inter-state transactions, ensuring that tax revenue is allocated to the state where goods or services are ultimately consumed. This model facilitates the seamless transfer of input tax credit across state lines, crucial for business owners engaged in nationwide operations. The filing of GST returns under the IGST model requires careful documentation of inter-state transactions, making GST registration and compliance a pivotal aspect of business operations. IGST effectively redistributes tax revenue among states, aligning with the destination principle of indirect taxation.

Union Territory Goods and Services Tax (UTGST)

UTGST applies specifically to transactions within Union Territories, functioning alongside CGST to tax goods and services. This ensures that Union Territories are integrated into the national GST framework, with business owners in these regions adhering to similar registration and filing protocols as their counterparts in states. UTGST simplifies the tax return process for businesses in Union Territories, reducing the indirect tax burden and facilitating a more uniform tax structure across the country.

The GST system, with its comprehensive approach to indirect taxation, has significantly eased the tax burdens on business owners, encouraging compliance through simplified tax returns, GST.

GST Advantages

The introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India has brought about significant changes in the tax landscape, offering numerous advantages that span from simplifying the tax system to boosting the economy. Here's a closer look at the key benefits GST has introduced:

Simplification of the Tax System

Prior to GST, the Indian tax system was mired in complexity, with a plethora of indirect taxes levied by both the central and state governments. GST has consolidated these multiple taxes into a single, unified tax regime, making it easier for businesses to understand their tax obligations. This simplification has significantly reduced the administrative burden on businesses, enabling them to focus more on their core activities rather than on navigating the complexities of the tax system.

Boost to the Economy

GST has been a catalyst for economic growth in India. By creating a single national market, it has eliminated the barriers to inter-state trade, such as entry taxes and check posts, thereby facilitating the smooth flow of goods and services across the country. This has not only increased the efficiency of logistics and distribution but also attracted foreign investment, as the tax system is now more transparent and business-friendly. The resultant increase in production and trade activities has contributed to the overall growth of the Indian economy.

Increase in Government Revenues

One of the primary objectives of GST was to broaden the tax base and increase government revenues, and it has been successful in achieving this goal. By simplifying the tax structure and making compliance easier, GST has encouraged more businesses to register and pay taxes, thereby increasing tax collections. Additionally, the system's design to minimize tax evasion through input tax credit mechanisms has further boosted government revenues.

Enhanced Compliance and Transparency

GST has introduced a technology-driven compliance system that has made the tax administration process more efficient and transparent. The GST portal enables electronic filing of tax returns, payment of taxes, and application for refunds, making the process faster and more reliable. This digital approach has not only reduced the chances of human error but also curbed corruption and tax evasion, leading to enhanced compliance and transparency in the tax system.

Removal of the Cascading Effect of Taxes

Perhaps one of the most significant advantages of GST is the elimination of the cascading effect of taxes, or "tax on tax." Under the previous tax regime, businesses were not able to claim input tax credits for all the taxes paid on inputs, leading to an increase in the cost of goods and services. GST allows businesses to claim input tax credit for the GST paid on inputs, reducing the cost of goods and services and making them cheaper for the end consumer. This has not only benefited consumers but also improved the competitiveness of Indian goods and services in the international market.

GST Disadvantages

Despite the numerous benefits brought about by the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in streamlining the indirect tax regime, it has also introduced several challenges and disadvantages, particularly affecting small indian businesses, the real estate sector, and compliance processes. Here are some of the key disadvantages associated with GST:

Compliance Costs for Small Businesses

Small businesses, especially those with limited annual turnover, have found themselves grappling with the increased compliance costs under GST. The need to adhere to the GST framework, including regular filings and digital record-keeping, has imposed financial and operational burdens on small enterprises that previously operated under simpler tax structures or were exempt from service tax and other indirect taxes.

Technological Challenges

The shift to a digital-first approach in tax filing and compliance under GST has posed technological challenges for many businesses. Those located in areas with limited access to reliable internet services or those lacking digital literacy have struggled to keep up with the requirements for online filings, digital invoices, and electronic payments, leading to disruptions in their operations.

Increased Operational Costs

The implementation of GST has led to increased operational costs for businesses across various sectors. This includes the costs associated with updating accounting software, training staff on GST compliance, and hiring tax consultants to navigate the complexities of the new tax regime. For businesses that engage in the supply of goods across state lines, understanding and managing the implications of IGST on interstate transactions has added to these operational challenges.

Impact on the Real Estate Sector

The real estate sector has experienced significant impacts due to GST, particularly in how it has affected project costs and, consequently, property prices. While GST has aimed to bring transparency and reduce tax evasion, the inclusion of real estate transactions under its purview has led to increased tax burdens on under-construction properties, affecting both developers and buyers.

Ambiguity and Complexity in Regulations

The GST framework, despite its intent to simplify the tax landscape, has introduced a level of ambiguity and complexity in regulations that businesses must navigate. This includes confusion over GST rates applicable to various goods and services, the classification of items under different tax slabs, and the interpretation of rules regarding input tax credits. Such ambiguities have made compliance more challenging and have led to uncertainties in tax planning and financial management for businesses.

In conclusion, while GST has unified the indirect tax regime and brought several advantages, it also presents a set of challenges that require attention and continuous refinement to ensure that the tax system supports the growth and sustainability of businesses across all sectors of the Indian economy.

💡You can use Pice Business Payment App to pay all your business expenses like GST, Vendor, Utilities and many more, with your credit card at the cheapest price.

FAQs